Came across this article this morning while checking out that Friday Night Lights review. And I am not happy with it. This writer seems to have forgotten 2 things: how to think like a kid, and that there are far worse things her child could be stuck on.
I admit that there are times that James' obsession with Star Wars can be a little overwhelming. But honestly it doesn't hurt him. The stories are a big morality play, just as much as any other popular fable. He has learned some basics like be kind to others, respectful of other living things etc. from watching the shows.
The way she writes about the show also shows to me that she doesn't have the child like attitude to truly appreciate the kids shows like Clone Wars. For me it is something we share. Yes I know in some respects that is more telling about me, but I am proud of the fact that I can still watch and appreciate 'kid's shows'. It strengthens the bond between me and my kids.
Last of course is her snobbish attitude about the prequels. I find it annoying that she can complain about the commercialism and violence, and then turn around and apply this grown up snobbish attitude towards the rest of the series. Star Wars is to me first and foremost a story. A fun story, with lots of really cool stuff. And there is some morality in there, but not as heavy handed as the Disney movies, which are ostensibly okay for kids. Heck there is far worse violence in the reading of Wizard of Oz where the Cowardly Lion decapitates creatures, then in most of the Star Wars movies.
I am not saying that she is wrong in her general review, but that she needs a better perspective. And that the other side has to be spoken for.
We're watching Clone Wars with the boys now, but waiting until Zevan is a little bit older to introduce the movies - possibly this summer, since he turns 5 soon. He's the obsessed one.
ReplyDeleteBut we would watch it with them the first time, of course. It's an experience we are excited about sharing with them.
*I'm* the one pressing for Star Wars family costumes this year.
Of course, as a mom, my geek factor is pretty high. :)